| Category #1 -- Best Couple |
|---|
| The Winner --> Buffy and Angel (123 Votes out of 196 Votes) |
| The Runner Up --> Willow and Oz (59 Votes out of 196 Votes) |
| The Loser --> Xander and Cordelia (14 Votes out of 196 Votes) | Category #2 -- Best "Fling Thing" Couple |
| The Winner --> Willow and Xander (95 Votes out of 198 Votes) |
| The Runner Up --> Joyce and Giles (85 Votes out of 198 Votes) |
| The Loser --> Buffy and Scott (18 Votes out of 198 Votes) | Category #3 -- Best Dressed Female |
| The Winner --> Buffy (126 Votes out of 196 Votes) |
| The Runner Up --> Faith (46 Votes out of 196 Votes) |
| The Loser --> Cordelia (24 Votes out of 196 Votes) | Category #4 -- Best Dressed Male |
| The Winner --> Angel (140 Votes out of 198 Votes) |
| The Runner Up --> Oz (36 Votes out of 198 Votes) |
| The Loser --> Xander (22 Votes out of 198 Votes) | Category #5 -- Best Supporting Cast Member |
| The Winner --> Faith (130 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Runner Up --> Joyce (42 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> Wesley (28 Votes out of 200 Votes) | Category #6 -- Best Villan |
| The Winner --> Vampire Willow (91 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Runner Up --> Faith (74 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> The Mayor (35 Votes out of 200 Votes) | Category #7 -- Best Slayerette |
| The Winner --> Willow (117 Votes out of 196 Votes) |
| The Runner Up --> Xander (54 Votes out of 196 Votes) |
| The Loser --> Oz (25 Votes out of 196 Votes) | Category #8 -- Best Kiss |
| The Winner --> Willow/Xander - "Homecoming" (122 Votes out of 193 Votes) |
| The Runner Up --> Cordelia/Wesley "Graduation Day Pt. 2" (40 Votes out of 193 Votes) |
| The Loser --> Joyce/Giles (31 Votes out of 193 Votes) | Category #9 -- Best Fight Scene |
| The Winner --> Buffy vs. Faith (Graduation Day Pt. 1) (103 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Runner Up --> Sunnydale High vs. The Mayor (Graduation Day Pt. 2) (81 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> Slayerfest '99 (Homecoming) (16 Votes out of 200 Votes) | Category #10 -- Outstanding Character for Season 3 |
| The Winner --> Buffy (96 Votes out of 196 Votes) |
| The Runner Up --> Angel (55 Votes out of 196 Votes) |
| The Loser --> Faith (45 Votes out of 196 Votes) |
| Category #11 -- Worst Episode of Season 3 |
| The Winner --> "Anne" (40 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Runner Up --> "Dead Man's Party" (32 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> **No Answer** (20 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "The Zeppo" (18 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Band Candy" (13 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Gingerbread" (10 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Amends" (8 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Helpless" (7 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "The Wish" (7 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "The Prom" (6 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Beauty and the Beast" (4 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Bad Girls" (4 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Revelations" (3 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Consequences" (3 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Doppelgangland" (3 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Graduation Day Pt. 2" (3 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Earshot" (2 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Faith, Hope, and Trick" (1 Vote out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Enemies" (1 Vote out of 200 Votes) | Category #12 -- Best Episode of Season 3 |
| The Winner --> "Gradutation Day Pt. 2" (35 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Runner Up --> "The Prom" (27 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Amends" (24 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Lover's Walk" (16 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "The Wish" (15 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Dopplegangland" (15 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Bad Girls" (11 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Graduation Day Pt. 1" (11 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Enemies" (8 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Earshot" (7 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Band Candy" (5 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Faith, Hope, and Trick" (4 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Helpless" (4 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Anne" (3 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "The Zeppo" (3 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> **No Answer** (2 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Dead Man's Party" (2 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Beauty and the Beast" (2 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Homecoming" (2 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Gingerbread" (2 Votes out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Consequences" (1 Vote out of 200 Votes) |
| The Loser --> "Choices" (1 Vote out of 200 Votes) |